Garbage as luxury.
What if garbage disposal was expensive, like Prada expensive? So if I don’t buy Prada because I can’t afford it, then I don’t create garbage because I can’t afford it. Garbage as luxury. The Jamb Juice Styrofoam cup Nicole Richie consummately carries could be as precious as her Christian Louboutin heels.
Imagine it costs $100 a pound to dispose of garbage. As a result when you purchase an item in a store, your decision making process now factors in the cost of disposal, of the product itself and/ or the packaging, before you purchase. We need a push/ accelerator/ catalyst to expedite the emergence of creative thinking & solutions to the garbage problem. Money will do that. Cost has done wonders for the gas crisis. I hope prices continue to rise- look at all of the investment & advancements in alternative energy. Electric cars used to be freakish things, and now we have an electric pickup truck that does 0 to 60 in 10 seconds.
In the case of Marrakesh restaurant, where I ate lunch today, the cashier tried to hand me a Styrofoam cup. I refused it and used my own glass at the soda fountain (violating some OSHA rule I am sure). Given my exploration of Styrofoam last evening, I realized it is actually cheaper for the restaurant to purchase Styrofoam cups (1000 16 oz. Styrofoam cups is $51.57) that to have reusable glass ones (and a commercial dishwasher, a hired dishwasher, increased water & electric bills). As a for-profit business, it is the right decision. In many cases like this, the economic breakdown is in favor of garbage.
However, if those cheap-o Styrofoam cups now cost $100 a day in disposal fees, suddenly the infrastructure & daily costs of a glass cups is starting to look comparable, or even better than Styrofoam. (During lunch, Jon Cho pointed out that this will simply drive people towards illegal dumping, but let’s entertain this idea a little longer)
Officially, the EPA calls this concept Pay as You Throw. It’s a not-so-extreme version of what I suggested above. In Austin, it costs $15 (plus tax!) to change the size of your garbage cart (that’s for an upsize or downsize- no real incentive there). Austin’s monthly rates are as follows.
30 gallon cart: $11.75 a month
60 gallon cart: $14.50 a month
90 gallon cart: $17.25 a month
The cost difference from the smallest can to the largest is a whole $5.50 per month, to create 240 extra gallons (60 gallons x 4 pickups per month) of garbage a month. Ooooo. $5.50. I’m scared.
I realize the point of public utilities is to provide the least inflated, most beneficial price to the citizen, but we’re not doing ourselves any favors here. We’ve only come to take it for granted and create problems with over consumption & massive landfills. What if we upped the price of garbage disposal and gave the profits to our schools? Or homeless cats?
Day 5: Personal garbage results
Confession time. A lot of people around the office have noticed that I have not exactly had my garbage within 5 feet of me at all times. It tends to linger in a rucksack on my desk or wherever my computer is, but I often forget to bring it to the snack room, bathroom, or on a run to the fax machine. And my loving colleagues have taken great care to give me trash talk about this. So starting tomorrow, I will wear a back pack, with my garbage in it.
I have to amend yesterday’s total. I added 2 straws to the pile last night. They were served in my margarita and it was too late to refuse it. Today’s total: No garbage! Here is my cumulative total for Day 5 (will post in the morning, my camera battery just ran out!)
http://designmind.frogdesign.com/trackback/670
Reminds me of Chris Rock on
Adam Richardson - May 18, 2007
Reminds me of Chris Rock on gun violence: Let's keep guns easy to get, but make bullets cost $5000 - each!
Check out this hilarious clip (profanity warning engaged)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eFcVwDw4YLE
What if throwing away a piece of garbage cost you personally $5000, per item?
Brilliant! The toilet
M@ - May 18, 2007
Brilliant! The toilet paper bill alone would move America to adobt Bidets as customary.
Seriously - packaging comes in two basic forms (save for the outmoded aluminum or tin can):
plastic and paper.
Plastic can ostensibly be gelatin or starch based for packaging, and paper can be cellulose or pulp. Both can be dissolved at home and then run down a drain. the things that have to hold liquids could be incinerated in my "Mr. Inferno"... probably designed by Stark and sold at Target. All the rest of the incidentals - like that toothpaste tube that you toss after 6 months of that minty freshness can be either recycled or incinerated. ... or composted.
Problem with bidets: what
Marvin - May 18, 2007
Problem with bidets: what happens when drinking water is scarce and we need to crank up the price of water?
Everything's a tradeoff, even toilet paper.
Just as a sideline - I am a
Jonathan Biddle - May 22, 2007
Just as a sideline - I am a British Industrial Designer in Taipei and our rubbish (trash) bags are actually fairly pricey. Like 50 cents for a small one, and I think (though I need to check) maybe 2 dollars for a big one. I might be lying though - I will check. 'Authentic' rubbish bags can only be put in the truck with the little logo sticker.
What it DOES do, is make you think.
- And as an aside, when the rubbish truck comes along it plays 'Green Sleaves' on speakers and everyone goes downstairs with their bags and chucks them in a truck. Another couple follow with cans and paper, and then there are usually some old guys taking any card or wood things (that they then sell).
I'll have to do a blog post!
There is a simple existing
David - May 24, 2007
There is a simple existing solution to the Pay as You Throw concept you mentioned: your garbage cart is equipped with an RFID or barcode. Its weight is logged as it picked up by the truck to be emptied. At the end of the month, you receive a bill with the total weight of trash picked up and its cost. This solution requires standardized carts.
It was tested a few years ago (can't remember where) in the east of France with great success. People started to care, choosing non-packaged food, composting etc.
As far as I remember, the experience had to be stopped because the amount of picked up trash went so low that it was jeopardizing the local incinerator profitability. And the company operating this facility had been smart enough to ensure itself a minimum trash tonnage supply guaranteed by contract!
As Marvin mentioned, everything’s a tradeoff.
There is no charge in Austin
Richard McHale - June 12, 2007
There is no charge in Austin if you would like a smaller cart. The $15 only applies if you are requesting a larger cart.
[...] a good experiment,
GarbageScout.com - Found treasure map to New York City, a re - June 17, 2007
[...] a good experiment, causing one partipant to muse about what it would be like if the cost of eventual disposal were borne by the consumer. Imagine it costs $100 a pound to dispose of garbage. As a result when you purchase an item in a [...]
Post new comment